Faculty Development Plan
Communications
2005
"The mission of Brigham Young University – founded,
supported, and guided by The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
– is to assist individuals in their quest for perfection and eternal
life. That assistance should provide a period of intensive learning in a
stimulating setting where a commitment to excellence is expected and the full
realization of human potential is pursued."
XXXX, assistant professor of communications
Department of Communications
Brigham Young University
Provo, Utah 84602
Tel. 801-422-xxxx
xxxx@byu.edu
______________________________________ ________________
Signature Date
OUTLINE FOR FACULTY DEVELOPMENT PLAN
I. Self-Assessment
- A. Teaching
- B. Research
- C. Citizenship
II. Professional Goals
A. Teaching
- 1. Goals and Plans
- 2. Relationship Between Individual Goals and Department and University Aspirations and Needs
- 3. Resources Needed
- 4. Activities and Accomplishments So Far
- 5. Comments on Measures Used to Assess Success
B. Research
- 1. Goals and Plans
- 2. Relationship Between Individual Goals and Department and University Aspirations and Needs
- 3. Resources Needed
- 4. Activities and Accomplishments So Far
- 5. Comments on Measures Used to Assess Success
C. Citizenship
- 1. Goals and Plans
- 2. Relationship Between Individual Goals and Department and University Aspirations and Needs
- 3. Resources Needed
- 4. Activities and Accomplishments So Far
- 5. Comments on Measures Used to Assess Success
I. SELF-ASSESSMENT
A. Teaching
- 1. Strengths:
- Professional experience. I have practiced professionally both as a journalist and a lawyer. Students attach credibility to real-world experiences dealing with material discussed in the classroom.
- Respect. I value and encourage student questions and contributions.
- 2. Weaknesses:
- Lack of teaching experience. Including the two semesters recently completed, I have taught only six semesters of university-level journalism and media law courses.
- "You're too nice." In my effort to accommodate and help students, I must guard against being a pushover.
- 3. Interests and Opportunities:
- Professional work and Christian service. I am enthusiastic about the opportunity to explore with students the ramifications of BYU's Mission and Aims.[ii] Taking a thought from former BYU Law School Dean Carl S. Hawkins, I believe this means making professional service part of our Christian ministry.[iii]
- Competence. I am enthusiastic about assisting students to become competent academically and professionally. For example, I am interested to collaborate with students on academic research and professional journalism.
B. Research
- 1. Strengths:
- Writing experience and ability. I have been a professional writer for 10 years in newspapers, magazines, trade publications and scholarly journals.
- Training and skill. Journalism and law school taught me to recognize “newsworthy” happenings, identify and describe trends, and analyze issues comprehensively. Law school training will greatly benefit me among communications scholars publishing on legal topics.
- 2. Weaknesses:
- Tendency to take on too much. Curiosity and desire can lead me to get involved in too many projects at once.
- Nature of my background. I am trained and experienced in legal research and writing and not more generally in social science research, including statistics.
- 3. Interests and Opportunities:
- Great material. There is much exciting breadth and depth to the research I can conduct on communications law. There should be no lack of interesting topics to research, think and write about.
- Becoming a public scholar. I would like my research not only to get out in the academic world but also to have a greater influence in society through sharing it with students, writing op-ed pieces in newspapers and submitting amicus curiae briefs to courts in communications law cases.
C. Citizenship
- 1. Strengths:
- Willingness. I am willing to get involved in various activities and work hard. I am enthusiastic about working with colleagues.
- Understanding of importance. I value making a difference in committee work and I realize the benefit I can gain by service.
- 2. Weaknesses:
- Lack of experience. Until the 2004-2005 academic year, I had not served on professional and academic committees.
- 3. Interests and Opportunities:
- Making service relevant and useful. I am interested in citizenship service for genuine reasons of contributing to the professions and to academia rather than just fulfilling a requirement.
II. PROFESSIONAL GOALS
A. Teaching
1. Goals and Plans:
Strengthen students spiritually. I will do this by:
- Creating writing assignments that require students to reflect on the meaning of making their professional work part of their Christian service.
- Fostering other experiences (such as final projects, volunteer positions) in which students can explore the meaning of professional work as Christian service
- Appropriately demonstrating my faith and testimony
Enlarge students intellectually. I will do this by:
- Creating challenging and rigorous assignments and exams that will be graded under “strict scrutiny.”
- Staying current in my discipline by reading new cases
- Publishing manuscripts on media law and journalism topics, thus allowing me to have something worthwhile to teach
Engaging in activities that will allow me to improve myself as a teacher and thus better help students to learn, such as:
Build students’ character. I will do this by:
- Reading about and discussing examples of professional communicators, lawyers and others, including Church leaders, who exhibit excellent character traits (for example, read and discuss portions of biography of J. Reuben Clark)
Foster students’ lifelong learning and service. I will do this by:
- Supervise internship experiences of print journalism students and respond to their weekly email updates with encouragement and teaching along the lines of not just doing well but also doing good.
- Mentoring graduate and undergraduate students as an internship supervisor, directed research supervisor, co-academic researcher and co-writer on professional journalism projects
- Achieve above-average teaching evaluations.
2. Relationship Between Individual Goals and Department and University Aspirations and Needs:
- Spiritually Strengthening. Students need examples of faculty members who “possess a remarkable diversity of gifts, but they all think of themselves as brothers and sisters seeking together to master the academic disciplines while remaining mastered by the higher claims of discipleship to the Savior.”[iv] I am striving to do this.
- Intellectually Enlarging. My goals seek to help students engage in sound thinking and effective communication as they develop skills and engage in broad and deep thinking.[v]
- Character Building. I am attempting to “reinforce such moral virtues as integrity, reverence, modesty, self-control, courage, compassion, and industry.”[vi]
- Lifelong Learning and Service. My goals seek to help students “learn, then demonstrate, that their ultimate allegiance is to higher values, principles, and human commitments rather than to mere self-interest.”[vii]
3. Resources Needed:
- Teaching assistants. With classes of 40 or more, the department will provide teaching assistant help.
- Technology training and support. I can get this through CID as well as the College’s computer support personnel.
4. Activities and Accomplishments So Far:
- Classes taught. In Fall 2004 I taught Communications 211 (News Writing), Communications 300 (Media Law, Ethics and Responsibility) and Communications 323 (News Editing). In Winter 2005 I taught Communications 406 (Advanced Media Law and Regulation), Communications 323 (News Editing) and Communications 300 (Media Law, Ethics and Responsibility).
- Evaluations. In Fall 2004 my instructor ratings were 6.7, 7.1 and 7.2. In Winter 2005 my instructor ratings were 7.0, 7.1 and 7.1. In addition, I received positive comments from students both formally and informally. I believe my efforts have benefited them.
- Christian service. In Winter 2005 I incorporated a service learning project in the structure of Comms. 406. Students engaged in interesting projects that benefited others and allowed them to explore the meaning of making their professional work part of their Christian service. Feedback was positive. Also, in both Comms. 300 and Comms. 323 students fulfilled a writing assignment reflecting on the meaning of making their professional work part of their Christian service.
- Faculty Center. I am participating in the Faculty Development Seminar. The Fall 2004 lunch meetings were very helpful. The Winter 2005 emphasis on mentoring has been helpful, as Kevin Stoker has provided me some feedback and a place to bounce ideas around. The Spring 2005 seminar promises to assist me greatly.
- American Press Institute. I was awarded a fellowship, as well as funding from the department and college, to attend the API Journalism Educators seminar June 12-17 in Reston, Virginia. This will assist me in course design, teaching and assessment.
- Writing Matters. I have been selected to participate in the Spring 2005 Writing Matters seminar here at BYU. This will help me in teaching students how to write.
- SCOT. In Winter 2005 I had three Students Consulting on Teaching – one for each of my classes. They provided valuable assistance and feedback.
- Rubrics. I sought help from the Faculty Center in assessing learning. Bryan Bradley and I discussed grading rubrics. I immediately implemented them in my classes for Winter 2005 and saw benefits of clarity for both myself and the students.
- Supervising internships. As a member of the print journalism faculty, I have supervised numerous students serving internships. In Fall 2004, I supervised one student. In Winter 2005, I supervised six students.
- Mentoring. In Winter 2005 I supervised four undergraduate communications studies students doing directed research. One of the students contributed to a paper I submitted to an academic conference. Additionally, my graduate research assistant in Winter 2005 is a coauthor for a paper I submitted to an academic conference.
- Self-administered evaluations. In Fall 2004, I administered midterm evaluations in all three courses I taught and used these to improve the remainder of the courses.
5. Comments on Measures Used to Assess Success:
- Evaluations. Student evaluations seem to provide some good feedback but appear incomplete in an overall assessment model. That is why I value the idea of creating a teaching portfolio that provides a more full and rich picture of my teaching.[viii]
B. Research
1. Goals and Plans:
- Publish two peer-reviewed articles per year. In order to accomplish this, I will submit at least one manuscript per year to either Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly or Journal of Communication and one manuscript per year to Communication Law & Policy. In addition, I will periodically submit manuscripts to other journals, such as Southwestern Mass Communication Journal, Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media and law journals.
- Present four conference papers per year. In order to accomplish this, I will submit manuscripts regularly to AEJMC (April 1 deadline), BEA (December 1 deadline), AEJMC SE Colloquium (Dec 1 deadline), Southwest (August 15 deadline) and ICA (November 1 deadline).
- Publish a book. Eventually, I will write a book on a communications law topic. In order to accomplish this, I will first concentrate on journal publications, which will establish my credibility and will allow me to explore possible topics.
- Write op-eds and look for opportunities to file amicus briefs.
2. Relationship Between Individual Goals and Department and University Aspirations and Needs:
- Purpose. My research goals facilitate accomplishing the purpose of scholarly research at BYU, which is “to serve God and humanity.”[ix] My scholarship seeks to “improv[e] the education of the minds and spirits of students” and “contribut[e] to the expansion of truth throughout the world.”[x] My scholarship will strengthen my teaching.
3. Resources Needed:
- Research assistant. Having a graduate research assistant (either communications graduate student or law student) on a regular basis would help me conduct research as I prepare to write manuscripts.
- Research reductions. A periodic reduction in class load would assist in accomplishing greater amounts of research.
- Funding. Funding through department, college, university and other sources will assist in obtaining necessary research materials. Funding might also support my research in spring or summer terms when I do not teach. An Ashton grant from the Department could facilitate graduate research assistant help in the spring and summer.
4. Activities and Accomplishments So Far:
- Publication. I published an article in January 2005 in the Santa Clara Computer & High Technology Law Journal.
- Conferences. I have presented papers during the 2004-2005 academic year at AEJMC, AEJMC Southeast Colloquium and BEA.
- Manuscripts under review. As of April 28, 2005, I have four manuscripts under review at conferences or journals.
- Awards. My paper at AEJMC 2004 placed third in the Law Division faculty paper competition. My paper at BEA 2005 placed first in the Law & Policy Division debut category.
- Op-ed. In January 2005 I published an op-ed piece in The Salt Lake Tribune on reporter’s privilege.
- Legal representation. In 2005 I represented a weekly Utah newspaper in a reporter’s privilege dispute. I drafted a document in opposition to a subpoena seeking material protected from disclosure by the First Amendment and common-law reporter’s privileges. The case was in U.S. District Court, and it looks like our efforts have been successful.
- Creative works. I have published six professional journalism pieces in the 2004-2005 academic year. These are in feature and trade magazines.
5. Comments on Measures Used to Assess Success:
- Law journals. I am concerned that manuscripts I publish in law journals be counted toward rank and status. I believe that even though law journals are not typically peer-reviewed (the editors are law students) they can be a valuable place for my research to reach large audiences of scholars, lawyers, judges and policymakers as well as the larger public. In the past, articles I have published in law journals have been cited by judges and federal agencies as well as other scholars.
C. Citizenship
1. Goals and Plans:
- Serve on a university committee. I want to contribute to Brigham Young University as I learn more about the functioning of its various aspects.
- Serve on department committees. I want to assist my colleagues in moving the work of our department forward.
- Serve in the larger community. I want to understand the community in which I live while giving of my time and talents.
- Become an officer of a national professional organization. I would like to become chair of the AEJMC Law Division or BEA Law & Policy Division someday. In order to accomplish this, I will begin to get involved in the activities of those divisions and eventually run for office.
- Collaborate with colleagues on research and teaching. I will join with colleagues in drafting manuscripts and developing teaching and assessment improvements.
2.Relationship Between Individual Goals and Department and University Aspirations and Needs:
- Purpose. My citizenship work will seek to demonstrate loyalty to the Church and to further the Mission and Aims of BYU. I will be collegial with students and faculty and participate productively in the life of the campus and the community.[xi]
3. Resources Needed:
- Funding. I may occasionally need funding to travel to meetings. For example, I was named a Core Member of the Teaching Committee in the ABA Forum on Communications Law. This group meets annually in either Florida or California.
4. Activities and Accomplishments So Far:
- BYU Scholarly Communications Committee. Since January 2005, I have served as a member of this university committee exploring solutions to the problem of the high cost of journal subscriptions.
- Provo School District Foundation Board of Directors. Since April 2005, I have been serving as a member of the board, with the specific responsibility to coordinate planned giving.
- BYU Department of Communications TRAC and search committees. I am serving as a member of these committees, charged respectively with travel and award funding decisions and faculty hiring recommendations.
- ABA Forum on Communications Law. I was named a Core Member upon start-up of the Teaching Committee. With gracious support from my department, I traveled to the annual meeting in January in Boca Raton, Florida.
- Utah Legal Services. In Winter 2005 I voluntereed as an attorney at Utah Legal Services and drafted an on-the-record request for determination in a Social Security disability case.
- Collaboration. I have written a research paper with a colleague, Allen Palmer, that was submitted for review in a conference and a journal. As a member of the print journalism faculty, I have attended various meetings to develop curriculum changes and review major admissions applications, among other business.
- Faculty meetings, devotionals, etc. I have made an effort to attend faculty meetings regularly. I can do better on devotionals; I usually watch on TV in my office but will attempt to attend live.
5. Comments on Measures Used to Assess Success:
- Criteria. I understand and support the idea that my citizenship is evaluated in part by loyalty to the Church, contributions to the Mission and Aims of BYU and “[b]ehavior reflecting honor, integrity, collegiality, civility, respect, concern for others, [and] adherence to the . . . Honor Code. . . .”[xii]
- Evidence. I understand that my citizenship will be assessed on evidence of (1) participation that strengthens the university, (2) active participation in the intellectual life, (3) willing service on committees, (4) collaboration with colleagues, (5) mentoring colleagues, (6) service to the profession, (7) employment of expertise in service to community and Church, and (8) attendance at meetings and devotionals.[xiii]
[i] Brigham Young University, The Mission of Brigham Young University and The Aims of a BYU Education 1 (1996) (mission statement originally approved by the BYU Board of Trustees Nov. 4, 1981; aims document originally approved by the BYU Board of Trustees March 1, 1995).
[ii] In fulfilling its mission “to assist individuals in their quest for perfection and eternal life . . . BYU seeks to develop students of faith, intellect, and character who have the skills and the desire to continue learning and to serve others throughout their lives.” Id. at 3.
[iii] Carl S. Hawkins, “Professional Service as a Christian Ministry,” in Galen L. Fletcher and Jane H. Wise, eds., Life in the Law: Answering God’s Interrogatories 164 (2002) (“When the Lord commands that we love him with all of our heart, might, mind and strength, he is not concerned so much with the intensity of our feelings as with the breadth and completeness of our commitment. For the committed Christian, every part of his or her being must become a living witness of love for Christ. Your life must become your ministry. Your roles as husband or wife, parent, friend, church worker, student, and [professional] must all become missions within that ministry, and your whole person, including your religious values, must become engaged in every part of that ministry.”).
[iv] Id. at 4.
[v] Id. at 5-7.
[vi] Id. at 10.
[vii] Id. at 13.
[viii] For more on teaching portfolios, see Brigham Young University, University Policy on Faculty Rank and Status 7 (2002).
[ix] Id. at 8.
[x] Id. at 8.
[xi] Id. at 5.
[xii] Id. at 5-6.
[xiii] Id. at 6.